November 23rd, 2014
10:52 AM ET

Family Fights Ordinance to Keep Beloved Pit Bull

Zeus doesn't bite. He's never exhibited aggressive behavior, either–according to his family.

But a city ordinance in Moreauville, Louisiana is telling them they have to "dispose" of Zeus– or they'll do it for them.

Zeus is a pit bull, and the Owens' story reignites the debate over the dangerousness of bully breeds.

"New Day Weekend" spoke with mother Joanna Armand and daughter O'Hara Owens who said Zeus is an essential member of their family.


Filed under: New Day Weekend
soundoff (4 Responses)
  1. AmyLynn

    Breed-Specific Legislation (BSL) is an unfair, prejudiced, and ineffective law that needs to be abolished, and the owners should ultimately be held responsible for their dog’s behavior. There is not a single breed of dog that has been proven to be inherently viscous; instead the way the animal is raised affects the animal’s temperament. Cities and towns that feel the need to enact laws regarding viscous dogs should start by addressing issues that play a role in a dog’s temperament such as; requiring certain breeds to be spayed/neutered, education on responsible ownership, and by holding owners responsible for their dog’s behavior and actions.

    November 29, 2014 at 1:12 pm | Reply
  2. RuthAnne Snell

    Many years ago, pit bulls were considered “Nanny dogs” because of their loyalty and gentleness toward their guardians. They were also once an American favorite, earning the title “America’s dog.”

    Unfortunately, people soon found ways to exploit pit bulls’ behaviors and tendencies for dog fights, and their strong appearance became a symbol of violence, drug culture and gangs.

    Today, pit bulls remain largely misunderstood because of irresponsible owners, sensationalist news stories, and a proliferation of myths. As a result, breed specific legislation (BSL) has popped up in cities across the U.S. that either greatly restricts or completely bans pit bull dogs as pets.

    The stigma that marks pit bulls has also contributed to their rise in U.S. shelters. One in four of all animals brought into shelters are pit bulls, and their average euthanasia rate hovers at 93 percent across the board.

    However, if given the chance, pit bulls can be very loving companions, and in some communities, they have even become heroes, saving people and their guardians from harm.

    Discover the top five reasons pit bulls are misunderstood below, then help debunk these myths by telling your family, friends and social media followers the real truth about pit bulls.
    Myth 1: Pit bull is a breed of dog

    “Pit bull” is actually a generic term applied to various breeds including the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Blue Blood Bulldog, Dogo Argentino and hundreds of mixed breeds of similar physical appearance.

    Therefore, the term “pit bull” often designates how a dog looks and not a breed itself, typically leading to a larger degree of misplaced blame on these dogs.

    Most people cannot actually spot the difference between a true American Pit Bull Terrier and other breeds. (Try to see if you can yourself with this test from Pit Bull Rescue Central. Find the answer key here.)

    In order to combat cruelty and misconceptions of all kinds, animal advocacy groups use the collective term “pit bull” to protect all breeds that are victimized because of their bully appearance.
    Myth 2: Pit bulls are born to fight

    Pit bull dogs are not born ready to rip into another dog, animal or human being. They are trained to fight by people who are interested in making a profit and providing “entertainment” in the form of a dog fight.

    These dogs are forced to fight to the death in many instances, and those who cannot go on are abandoned, or killed by electrocution, gunshot, or other cruel means. It is then not the dogs who are cruel and vicious, but rather those behind their training.
    Myth 3: Pit bulls are naturally violent, aggressive and mean, and are very dangerous dogs

    Pit bulls are not inherently dangerous. Like any other dogs, they can become violent, aggressive and mean through a lack of training, abuse, neglect and irresponsible ownership and breeding as well as a lack of attention to health and temperament issues. If they are treated with respect and trained properly, pit bulls will exhibit little to no negative traits (just ask a loving pit bull adopter!)

    In fact, according to the American Temperament Test Society, American Pit Bull Terriers, the most popular breed used in dog fights, have a very high temperament passing rate of 82.6 percent. Even dogs commonly thought to be kind and gentle (and they are, with the right care) like Bearded Collies and Chihuahuas scored lower than American Pit Bull Terriers.
    Myth 4: Pit bulls have locking jaws

    This myth, like the others, is completely false. According to the ASPCA, there is nothing “unique about the anatomy of [a] pit bull jaw.” What’s more, leading veterinary experts including Dr. Howard Evans and Dr. Sandy deLahunta, both of Cornell University, have stated that there is “no such thing as a ‘jaw locking’ in any breed,” as reported by Pit Bull Rescue Central.

    Pit bulls do indeed have strong jaw muscles and their fighting style is one that involves grabbing and shaking, but that does not mean once they get a grip they can’t or won’t let go.
    Myth 5: Pit bulls have a high bite rate

    Dog bite statistics are often unfairly skewed to paint pit bulls as the primary perpetrators. Moreover, dog bite or attack stories involving a bully breed are typically written in a way that demonizes the dog and sensationalizes the story, further fueling fear and misconceptions about pit bulls.

    According to the American Veterinary Medical Association, “It is not possible to calculate a bite rate for a breed… [because] mixed breeds are commonly described as purebreds … [and] the actual number of bites that occur in a community is not known … if they did not result in serious injury.”

    This is not to say that certain dogs are not responsible for bites or attacks. Rather, it highlights that perhaps there is more to the story than is actually being reported (i.e. poor training and care, and in some cases, the victim has actually provoked the dog).

    November 24, 2014 at 1:05 am | Reply
  3. J.

    Bully breeds?

    Imagine being so biased you can't make impartial statements.

    2.5/10 would not waste my time on CNN.com again.

    November 24, 2014 at 12:21 am | Reply
  4. Shay

    Pit bulls and "bully" dogs were first bred as nanny dogs. They used to sit on the porch of it's family (usually farmers) and care for the small children. If the baby/child was distressed, the dog's responsibility was to go and fetch the child's caretaker. They were EXTREMELY successful for many years in this capacity. It wasn't until people started using them to fight that their character/disposition was ever called into question. If people want to get factual, the biggest dog biters are cocker spaniels. They bite more people than ANY OTHER breed.

    November 23, 2014 at 8:45 pm | Reply

Leave a Reply to RuthAnne Snell


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.